Cannibal Island is one of the more difficult (read: nigh impossible) scenarios of the six found in the Robinson Crusoe box. This was the intro game for three of the four players, which we offset by lowering the difficulty in two ways. First, we brought the dog to help with exploring and hunting, both crucial actions in this scenario where we need to find and destroy cannibal villages. Second, we forgot to use the 4-player of Arrange Camp action, which meant we had a few extra morale and determination tokens (to immediately lose.)
Needless to say, it didn’t go well.